Reform index №189-190: several reforms and two anti-reform regulations - tax and customs incentives for industrial parks

Reform index №189-190: several reforms and two anti-reform regulations – tax and customs incentives for industrial parks

Photo: / oleksii.chumachenko
17 August 2022

In issue 189-190 (issue 185 before the audit) of the Reform Index, 16 changes have been included for the period from June 20 to July 17*, which can impact the “rules of the game” in the country. Of them, two are ant-ireform: laws on tax and customs incentives creating favorable conditions for industrial parks. Overall, during this period, the Reform Index reached a value of +1, within possible values ranging from -5.0 to +5.0. In the previous issue, the Index was +0.8 points. 

*In connection with the war in Ukraine and the state’s change of focus to wartime needs for the period of active hostilities, we have changed the period of monitoring regulations for the Index for Monitoring Reforms from two to four weeks.

Chart 1. Reform Index Dynamics

Chart 2. Reform Index and its components in the current round

Ratifying the Istanbul Convention: +3.0 points

After the many years of attempts, Ukraine passed law 2319-IX ratifying the Istanbul Convention and joined the 35 countries that ratified it earlier. Great Britain ratified the Convention almost immediately after Ukraine. 

The convention not only obliges signatory countries to criminalize gender-based violence (forced marriage, forced sterilization, stalking, etc.) to enshrine the principle of equal rights for women and men in legislation but also offers tools to prevent violence. These include information campaigns to raise public awareness of various forms of gender-based violence, adapted material used in the educational process, training specialists to deal with victims or perpetrators of any acts of violence falling under the Convention; and preventive intervention and treatment programs and programs involving businesses and the media in preventing violence against women and increasing respect for their dignity.

Countries ratifying the Convention undertake to collect statistics on instances of all forms of violence falling under the Convention to monitor its implementation’s effectiveness.

Information about the Reforms Index project, the list of Index experts and the database of the regulations assessed are available here.

“Visa-free transport regime” with the EU: +2.5 points

On June 29, Minister of Infrastructure Oleksandr Kubrakov signed on behalf of Ukraine an agreement with the European Union on cargo transportation by road. It cancels out the need for Ukrainian carriers to obtain permits for bilateral and transit transportation through EU countries, accelerating the movement of cargo transport across the border. The agreement is especially helpful now when Ukraine has lost the capability to transport goods by air and partly by sea due to Russia’s invasion, which has increased the demand for road transportation. 

Besides, according to the agreement, Ukraine and the EU will mutually recognize driver’s licenses issued by one of the parties. Therefore, Ukrainians will not need international permits to drive a car in the EU.

Law on improving the provision of medical care, +2.0 points

Law 2347-IX takes another step in reforming the healthcare system. In particular, it unites the secondary and tertiary tiers of medical care into specialized medical care, improves the functioning of hospital districts and provision of palliative care, and creates the basis for reimbursement for medicines. Another practical development is the amendments to the Civil Code, requiring criminal offenders to compensate the state budget for the costs of victim’s treatment. 

The law also expands the powers of the Cabinet of Ministers. The latter now has the right to set the minimum wage for healthcare workers. On the one hand, it is an important step to encourage doctors and nurses to stay in medicine. On the other hand, it undermines the autonomy of hospitals, affecting their financial model.

Technical and vocational education can be obtained for a second time for free, +2.0 points

According to Kyiv School of Economics, at least 388 Ukrainian enterprises have been damaged, destroyed, or seized since the beginning of the full-scale russian invasion. This means the loss of jobs and a decrease in demand for certain professions (e.g., metallurgical production has halved) and brings the need for Ukrainians to retrain for jobs that are more in demand on the labor market. In order to facilitate this process, the Verkhovna Rada adopted Law 2312-IX, making it possible to get vocational education for a new profession, for a second time for free if at least three years have passed since the completion of the first one, if one has a pensionable service record, and if the educational institution has vacant study places. However, applying for free vocational training even earlier and without pensionable service records is possible if person cannot work in he r/ his previous occupation due to health conditions or if a new profession is needed to meet the state’s immediate needs.

Law on protecting state information resources: +2.0 points

Since Ukraine’s information resources have been subjected to constant attacks by russia, it became necessary to secure Ukrainian electronic resources and registers. To this end, Law 2130-IX enables owners of state information resources to conclude technical administration agreements with foreign cloud service providers.

Owners are also tasked with creating backup copies of state information resources in separate physical media in encrypted form and ensuring their safe storage. It can also be done in other countries: in Ukrainian foreign diplomatic institutions during martial law in Ukraine and six months after its lifting.

It is forbidden to use cloud resources and store backup copies in the occupied territories or in aggressor states and countries that are part of customs and military alliances with the aggressors.

Law on waste management: +2.0 points

Law 2320-IX initiates waste management reform in Ukraine. It harmonizes Ukrainian legislation with European laws, creating a similar waste management hierarchy. The hierarchy involves the following waste management methods (in order of priority): waste prevention, waste reuse, recycling (processing for reuse), recovery (energy production), and waste disposal. In order to implement this hierarchy framework, the law introduces a system of long-term waste management planning at the national, regional, and local levels. The law also establishes the “polluter pays” principle and outlines possible violations of waste management laws.

Qualified electronic trust services provided in the EU will be recognized in Ukraine’s banking and payments spheres (+0.5 points)

Ukraine’s decision to recognize e-signatures and qualified electronic seals created in the EU significantly simplifies interaction between the European and Ukrainian banking systems.

Customs (-2.0 points) and tax (-1.3 points) benefits to create favorable conditions for industrial parks

In this issue, we also spotted two anti-reform regulations having to do with another attempt to support industrial parks. A few years ago, VoxUkraine’s editorial board wrote about why the benefits would not turn Ukrainian industrial parks into a new Silicon Valley.

The Verkhovna Rada adopted changes to the Tax and Customs Codes to create favorable conditions for attracting large-scale investments into the economy.

Key benefits include:

  • exemption from paying income tax for ten years if a company has the status of industrial park (IP) participant for at least ten years. But there is a nuance: the saved funds must be spent exclusively in the following tax year to develop the company within the industrial park. But should this condition be violated, the participant must pay the unused part of the amount as income tax and a penalty for late payment, losing the right to the benefit for the next period;
  • exemption from paying VAT when importing equipment used in the industrial park. However, if a company loses the IP participant status less than five years after the date of importing the equipment, it must pay VAT for the equipment, as well as a penalty for late payment;
  • permission for local self-government bodies to reduce the tax on land and real estate, rent for land or objects within the IP for industrial park participants.

The disadvantages of the new norms are, firstly, a reduction in tax and customs revenues in wartime without guarantees of the economy’s genuine revival due to the influence of industrial parks, secondly, distortions created in the market where certain areas get favorable terms at the expense of the comparatively deteriorating terms in other places, and thirdly, an attempt to selectively support some territories and enterprises instead of creating equal, comfortable conditions for all businesses in Ukraine.

Chart 3. Value of Reform Index components and number of events

Reform Index from VoxUkraine aims to provide a comprehensive assessment of reform efforts by Ukraine’s authorities. The Index is based on expert assessments of changes in the regulatory environment in six areas: Governance, Public Finance, Monetary system, Business Environment, Energy, Human Capital.

This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of Vox Ukraine and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union.



The author doesn`t work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have no relevant affiliations